Returning, Not Repeating

introduction
philosophy
Author

Alonso Espinosa Domínguez

Published

March 14, 2026

Modified

November 1, 2026

Despite a couple of terrible math teachers I had early in middle school (the kind that cause most people to loathe math for the rest of their lives), by the end I still fell in love with the subject. From that point forward, I spent much of my time chaotically pursuing anything and everything that caught my eye mathematically. I got an intoxicating taste of the awesome experience of forming a conjecture and then, after pondering over it for days or weeks, finally proving it wrong or right. I went on to major in math during college at MIT, engaged in a few attempted research projects (one of which eventually led to a joint publication), and graduated with a math degree in 2020. I then stopped doing math for a few years.

My departure from the subject was not precisely graceful. By the time I graduated, I was, I guess you could say, rather “burnt out”. For sure, much of that exhaustion was self-inflicted. For instance, taking a graduate-level measure theory course my freshman spring was, in retrospect, not the wisest decision. My brash, impatient impulse to advance as fast as possible in the topics that interested me while skipping over everything else shot me in the foot over and over again while in college. Each time, I managed not to learn the appropriate lesson.

This is perhaps not too surprising, given the fact that I had been using math as a kind of crutch. Like many in our messed-up capitalist society, I have had my share of struggles with anxiety, depression, and the like. In the years before falling in love with math, these struggles were particularly acute and characterized by a profound sense of purposelessness. Discovering at age 13 or so that I really liked math and that, with sufficient tenacity, I could advance considerably beyond the standard school curriculum gave me a sense of purpose and self-worth. Not to mention, it also provided an escape from problems in my life and in the world around me.

Inevitably this dynamic began to eat away at the joy of engaging in the difficult struggle of learning math and (later on) of carrying out research. Math is hard, and it is hard for everyone. “There is no royal road to geometry,” as Euclid reportedly said, nor is there one to science in general as Marx later added. But when “success” in math (or any other pursuit) becomes a substitute for a sense of self-worth, the challenges and failures one comes up against can easily become supposed signs of irremediable inadequacy. This frame of mind naturally also facilitates falling into a frankly silly competitive dynamic. For some of us in college, for instance, the number of grad classes we took as undergrads became a ridiculous metric by which we judged our future prospects. The result was to render the tortuous path of learning and discovery into a torturous one that ceases to actually be primarily about learning or discovery.

The consequences of the aforementioned mistakes in my approach were certainly a major contributing factor to my lengthy departure from math. They were far from the only factor, however. In parallel to my “burnout,” I was also increasingly drawn to struggles against various outrages in society. From cozying up to Mohammed bin Salman while he was the lead architect of the atrocious US-armed Saudi war against Yemen, to establishing ties with Jeffrey Epstein, and much more, MIT provided no shortage of examples to fight against.

So, as I started moving away from math, I didn’t take any time to rest, or to reflect terribly much on my time doing mathematics. Instead, I threw myself into organizing: first at MIT, and then amongst public housing tenants, at my unionized workplace, and elsewhere. I read up on Marxism, history, some philosophy, and generally spent a lot of time thinking a lot about the material forces shaping society in a way I had not quite done before. This changed my worldview considerably; unsurprisingly, it also thoroughly changed how I see mathematics.

Up until around halfway through college, my view of the subject and of reality more generally was vaguely Kantian. Teenage me became convinced that whatever objective reality (the realm of “things in themselves”) might be, we couldn’t truly know anything about it. The only knowledge I thought we could form from the “chaotic diversity of our sense experience”1 with this reality was knowledge about ourselves, i.e. about how we experience things, whilst the things themselves remained fundamentally out of reach. Science, I thought, was the process of imposing structure on this chaotic diversity so as to make it amenable to a coherent system of thought, and nothing more. Since the most definite and coherent systems of thought were mathematical, mathematics seemed to me a study of the finest and most powerful structures the mind has for arriving at the only kind of knowledge it can form.

I started seriously questioning this view just before I fully threw myself into politics and activism, largely because of how incompatible it is with the jarring concreteness of social and political life. If the structures of the mind are what matter most, then what do I make of the fact that people face material oppression and exploitation right now, in ways that have nothing to do with mental structures? (at least not in the sense I had been thinking about “mental structures”).

All these years later, by no means have I arrived at anything like a worked-out philosophy of math or of anything else. But if I had to roughly summarize the basic suppositions which I now take as a starting point, they would include:

  1. there is a real, objective, material world;
  2. we represent it mentally and symbolically;
  3. our representations improve precisely through the process of acting in the world and confronting the consequences;
  4. this process results in direct, albeit partial, knowledge of reality.

From this vantage point, mathematics looks rather different. The objects of mathematics – numbers, relations, structures, sets, categories, so on – are not constructs of the mind projecting itself outward to generate the only domain we can form knowledge of. On the contrary, they are real features of material reality that we have learned, over the course of millennia, to perceive, abstract, and reason about. And we have learned to do so by actively intervening (or perhaps the better word is laboring) to transform this material reality in pursuit of variety of largely socially-determined ends. Just think of the role of land surveying in the history of the emergence of geometry.

This shift in perspective helped me reopen the door to the world of mathematics; mathematics’ wonders have done the rest of the work needed to draw me back in fully.

And so, Mathematical Adventures is, first of all, an attempt to actually do mathematics again, and to do so in an adventurous spirit. After all these years, I am certainly rusty, and I need a good deal of practice thinking about and writing mathematics. This will include posing a ton of mathematical questions and documenting the messy process of trying to answer them. But I also intend to make it a place for the kind of meta-mathematical reflection I have hinted at here. So, expect to see some explorations into the philosophy of math, its history, its relationship to other sciences, and its relationship to our class-divided society at large.

The first series, Pathological Periodicity, is squarely in the first category2 — a deep dive into the surprisingly rich world of periodic functions that began with a single exercise in Chapter 1 of a linear algebra textbook. Later posts will venture further into the second.

Footnotes

  1. “Science is the attempt to make the chaotic diversity of our sense-experience correspond to a logically uniform system of thought.” This is the opening line in Einstein’s essay “The Fundamentals of Theoretical Physics”, which can be found in the collection Out of My Later Years. As a teenager I found myself returning to this line repeatedly.↩︎

  2. Ironically, Pathological Periodicity will take us into some deep set-theoretic territory involving the Axiom of Choice, where the philosophical view of mathematics I sketched above is seemingly hardest to defend. Stay tuned for a philosophical follow-up to that series.↩︎

Stay in touch

If you enjoyed this post or spotted an error, I'd love to hear from you. You can reach me at alonso@mathadventures.blog

Subscribe

You can follow this blog via RSS feed.

Share

If you found this useful, consider sharing it with someone who might enjoy it too.